
How to Evaluate a New EHR for an Orthopedic Surgery Practice 2026
November 17, 2026
Last updated:


Choosing a new EHR is a major decision for an orthopedic surgery practice. A system change affects clinical documentation, imaging, billing, patient records, staff workflows and the tools your team relies on every day. The right platform should simplify those workflows rather than introduce another layer of disconnected software.
Athelas offers two complementary solutions for orthopedic practices evaluating their technology and revenue cycle operations: Athelas Air, an AI-native EHR and practice management platform with billing built in, and Athelas RCM, a managed revenue cycle service that combines Athelas software with a dedicated billing team.
Practices can use Athelas Air to consolidate clinical documentation, scheduling, practice management and billing software while keeping revenue cycle operations in-house. Practices that want to outsource billing can add Athelas RCM to Air or use RCM alongside their existing EHR without replacing their clinical system.
This guide walks through eight steps for evaluating a new orthopedic EHR, from integration requirements and record retention to staff training, billing options and implementation timelines.
Key takeaways
- Test connections with your own charts. A demo shows what a vendor wants you to see, not necessarily how your imaging, dictation and billing tools will behave.
- Settle record access first. Ask for the export format, a sample file and the read-only access window before discussing price.
- Train in waves. Keep clinic days running by moving one team, one location or one day at a time.
- Choose your billing model deliberately. Decide whether your practice will manage billing internally through its EHR, keep its existing billing vendor or outsource revenue cycle operations through a managed RCM service.
- Understand the difference between Air and RCM. Air provides the integrated EHR, practice management and billing platform. RCM provides a managed billing team. Practices can use either or combine both.
- Plan for the full transition. Account for historical records, clearinghouse access, existing contracts, duplicate resources and staff training.
In 20% of analyzed calls with orthopedic surgery practices, the practice raised concerns about a fragmented technology stack and workarounds. These are observations from recorded conversations, not results from a representative survey.
How do I evaluate whether a new EHR integrates with my existing clinical and billing tools?
Start by identifying which tools your practice needs to keep and which workflows you want to consolidate.
Orthopedic practices often rely on several connected systems for clinical documentation, imaging, dictation, scheduling, billing and patient communication. Before selecting a replacement EHR, determine whether the new platform can connect to the systems you depend on or replace them with integrated capabilities.
Athelas Air is an AI-native EHR and practice management platform with billing software built in, designed for independent and multi-site outpatient practices, including orthopedic groups. It brings clinical and administrative workflows together under one per-provider platform price and provides documented FHIR API access and patient information exports.
For practices that want to outsource billing, Athelas RCM provides managed revenue cycle services through Athelas software and a dedicated billing team. RCM can work with Air or alongside an existing EHR, so an orthopedic group does not have to replace its clinical system to use Athelas for revenue cycle management.
The best approach depends on your existing technology and operational goals:
- Replace your EHR and consolidate practice management and billing software: Evaluate Athelas Air.
- Keep your current EHR but outsource billing: Evaluate Athelas RCM.
- Replace your EHR and outsource billing: Evaluate Athelas Air + RCM.
- Keep your existing billing arrangement temporarily: Confirm that your new EHR supports the necessary claims and data handoffs.
Groups tied to imaging, dictation or billing vendors they cannot replace should run the integration checks below against every vendor on their shortlist.
What are the steps to evaluate a new orthopedic EHR?
Work through these eight steps in order. Each one ends with something you can verify before signing a contract.
1. Map your current technology stack.
List every tool that touches a patient or a claim: imaging and PACS, dictation, fax, clearinghouse, billing company and patient portal. Mark what stays, what goes and who administers each system.
This is also the time to identify which functions you want in your new EHR versus which you may want to outsource. For example, an orthopedic group might use Air to consolidate its clinical and billing software while retaining internal billing staff, or combine Air with RCM to outsource revenue cycle operations.
2. Ask how each connection works.
Is the connection an interface, an API, a file transfer or manual re-keying? Ask who sets it up, whether your administrator needs technical skills and whether the vendor can shut off an outside tool during your contract.
If you're evaluating a platform with built-in billing, determine whether claims, charges and payment information move through the same system or require a separate integration.
3. Read the API documentation before the demo.
Look for published standards such as FHIR (Fast Healthcare Interoperability Resources), named data scopes and bulk access. If a vendor cannot share documentation, treat the connection as custom work until proven otherwise.
4. Rebuild your own templates in a test.
Load your initial evaluation, post-op visit, injection note, flowsheets and outcome measures. Compare every field and score against your current chart, and have a surgeon and a medical assistant sign off.
If the platform includes Ambient AI or another documentation assistant, test whether it writes into the note sections and templates your providers actually use.
5. Pin down record retention.
Request the export format, a sample file and a timeline for a full export that includes documents. Ask how long read-only access to your previous EHR will remain available and whether it carries an additional cost.
One orthopedic practice spent nearly two years pulling documents by hand from old systems after a legacy vendor failed, and staff still sort incoming faxes into buckets. An orthopedic owner-clinician who is an employee with no ownership of current records says he will leave his vendor if outside-records exchange fails. A podiatry practice moving off its EHR plans about 90 days of read-only access to the old system so staff can check old notes.
6. Plan training around live clinic days.
Use one super-user per role, short sessions between patients and a lighter schedule in week one. Ask for training on the administrative backend, including automations and settings.
One billing customer's prior vendor set up the system without explaining the admin backend, and nobody turned off its automations when the vendor left. An orthopedic surgeon who tried a vendor's training said it would not fit his workflow because he wants to record only level of service and diagnosis rather than click through screens.
7. Choose the billing path.
Decide whether your team will manage billing internally, retain its current billing company or transition to a managed RCM service. The decision table below explains how each option changes your implementation requirements.
8. Build the timeline and the cost.
Work backward from your contract end date. One orthopedic practice's current EHR contract renews for two to three years, and its leadership needs six to nine months of lead time. Another orthopedic practice needs a go/no-go timeline working back from a September 2027 deadline and wants to avoid paying for duplicate resources during a parallel run.
Include implementation, data migration, training, clearinghouse access, billing services and any remaining third-party subscriptions in your total cost comparison.
Which billing path fits: keep my biller, use one platform or outsource revenue cycle management?
The right branch depends on your billing contract, clearinghouse access, current EHR and how much operational change your team can absorb at once.
It's important to distinguish between an integrated billing platform and a managed billing service. An EHR with built-in billing software gives your team the tools to manage claims and payments. A managed RCM service provides the people and operational support to perform revenue cycle work on your practice's behalf.
Billing handoffs can stall on access. One orthopedic practice moving its revenue cycle to a new partner found that its current billing company still held clearinghouse access, and only one biller could submit claims at a time. Its handoff date was tied to the old contract end.
Before making a decision, clarify who owns clearinghouse access, who submits claims during the transition and how outstanding accounts receivable will be handled.
What should I do when integrations or training go wrong?
Stop the rollout at the next checkpoint rather than pushing forward with an unresolved issue. Then work through the problem from the smallest unit.
- A connection fails. Keep a manual fallback for orders, charges and faxes, and set a date to retest rather than leaving the issue open.
- Data arrives incorrectly. Fix the field in the source system. Air's sync documentation says a wrong field in your EHR arrives wrong, so correct it where it starts.
- Training stalls. Pause the next location, retrain the super-users and use real schedules instead of sample patients.
- Administrative gaps appear. Ask for a written list of every automation, who owns it and how to turn it off.
- Old records are missing. Keep read-only access to the old system until the export is checked against a sample of charts.
- Billing operations are interrupted. Confirm clearinghouse access, identify who is responsible for submitting claims and establish a temporary process for outstanding claims and payments.
If your practice is using Athelas Air with internal billing, make sure your billing staff understand the platform's workflows before go-live. If you're adding Athelas RCM, clarify the transition plan, responsibilities and communication process between your practice and the managed billing team.
How does Athelas Air handle API access, record retention and migration?
Athelas Air publishes its developer documentation, allowing orthopedic practices to review API capabilities and export formats before committing to a migration.
The platform also combines clinical documentation, practice management and billing software, reducing the need to coordinate those functions across separate systems. Practices that want to outsource billing can add Athelas RCM to the platform.
Key capabilities include:
- FHIR API. Air's developer documentation describes the Commure EHR FHIR API, which conforms to HL7 US Core 6.1.0 on FHIR R4 and supports the USCDI v3 data set.
- Standards for apps and bulk data. It lists SMART App Launch v2.0.0 and FHIR Bulk Data Access v2.0.0, with patient-level scopes for resources such as encounters, clinical documents, conditions and implantable devices.
- Patient information export. Air's EHI Export covers a single patient or the whole practice, and its output includes claims.csv, a C-CDA XML document and the documents uploaded to the chart.
- Who can export. Providers and admins can export one patient, an account admin requests a site-wide export, and every export is recorded in the audit log.
- EHR Data Sync. If you keep your current EHR for now, Air's data sync reads appointment date, status and type, with demographics and insurance linked from the patient record. It reflects your EHR exactly, so an empty or wrong field arrives empty or wrong.
- Outcomes reporting. The Retention Engine reports functional outcome coverage at evaluation, progress note and discharge, giving practices a way to check outcome measures after a move.
- Migration timing. Migrations can be completed in 30–60 days based on practice complexity. Book time with our team to plan yours.
For practices that want to retain their existing EHR but change how billing is handled, Athelas RCM offers another path. The managed service can work alongside the current clinical platform without requiring an immediate EHR migration.
Read the Air FHIR API documentation and the patient information export guide against your own requirements, and see how EHR Data Sync and the Retention Engine work.
Which EHR migrations does Athelas Air support, and what data can move?
Athelas Air supports migrations from the systems below. This is a migration into Air, not live two-way integration. The data overview summarizes each documented migration, and available exports and your workflow determine the project scope.
What results have orthopedic practices seen with Athelas?
These figures come from published Athelas case studies, as of 2026. Each represents the results of an individual practice.
- Dr. Arthur J Ting (orthopedics; Athelas Air, Athelas RCM, Ambient AI and Commure Agents): More than 80% year-over-year revenue growth, an 80% first-pass claim rate, a 92% total collection rate and 15 minutes saved per patient appointment. Read the Dr. Ting case study.
- Raleigh Orthopaedic (orthopedics, more than 140 providers; Athelas Air, Athelas RCM and Ambient AI): 81.5% reduction in pending site-related work items week over week, 15.3% increase in weekly revenue posted and AI-powered authorization denial review achieving 81.1% accuracy. Read the Raleigh Orthopaedic case study.
- Ortho Plus (orthopedics; Athelas RCM): $368K in additional patient revenue collected, $56K recovered from 951 previously denied claims, a 1.9% denial and rejection rate and a 91% first-pass rate. Read the Ortho Plus case study.
These examples illustrate how orthopedic practices can use integrated EHR and practice management software, managed revenue cycle services and AI-powered documentation to improve clinical and financial workflows.
The examples also demonstrate that practices do not have to choose the same configuration. Dr. Ting and Raleigh Orthopaedic use Air and RCM together, while Ortho Plus uses RCM. The appropriate setup depends on whether a practice wants to replace its EHR, outsource billing or make both changes.
What should I ask before I choose a new EHR?
Use this checklist in vendor meetings and pilots.
- Can you show the API documentation today? Look for named standards and scopes, not a promise of custom work.
- What is the process and timeline for a full export? Include documents, faxes and attachments, and ask for a sample file.
- How long is read-only access to the old EHR, and what does it cost? Match it to your parallel-run plan.
- Who sets up each integration, and does my administrator need technical skills?
- Can the vendor block or shut off an outside tool during the contract?
- Will an ambient scribe write into note sections, or will staff need to copy and paste?
- Can I test on my own templates, flowsheets and outcome measures before committing?
- What administrative backend training do we get, including automations and settings?
- Does the platform include billing software, managed billing services or both?
- If I use a managed RCM service, which revenue cycle responsibilities does the vendor handle and which remain with my practice?
- Can I keep my current EHR if I want to outsource billing without migrating clinical records?
Take one fixed order into your next meeting: connections, records, templates, training, billing and timeline.
Request an Athelas Air demo to run the checklist on your own workflow, with pricing scoped to your provider count, specialty and current setup. If your primary goal is to outsource billing, ask about Athelas RCM and how it can work with your current EHR or Athelas Air.
Frequently asked questions
What should an orthopedic surgery practice require from an EHR for imaging, orders and documentation?
Require a documented way to connect your imaging and PACS tools, a test with your own order and note templates, and a clear answer on who sets up each connection.
Athelas Air publishes a FHIR API with named data scopes, so you can review how outside tools connect before a demo. Test imaging and order workflows on real visits, not sample patients.
Should we keep separate EHR and billing systems or move to one integrated platform?
It depends on your billing contract, clearinghouse access and whether your practice wants to manage billing internally or outsource it.
Athelas Air combines EHR, practice management and billing software under one per-provider platform price. Practices using Air can continue managing billing internally.
Athelas RCM is a separate managed revenue cycle service for practices that want Athelas to handle billing operations. It can work alongside an existing EHR or be combined with Air.
If you want to consolidate your software and outsource billing, Air + RCM combines both offerings.
How can we retain access to old patient records after changing EHR vendors?
Ask the old vendor for a full export that includes documents, and keep read-only access until you have checked a sample of charts.
Air also supports migrations from many EHRs, and its own export covers one patient or the whole practice, including claims data, a C-CDA document and uploaded attachments.
What EHR API access is available for connecting our other practice software?
Air's developer documentation describes a FHIR API that conforms to HL7 US Core 6.1.0 and supports USCDI v3, with SMART App Launch and bulk data access listed.
Review the scopes against the tools you need to connect, such as encounters, documents and conditions.
How can we train staff on a new EHR while keeping the clinic running?
Train in waves by role, location or day, and name one super-user per role. Use real schedules, keep a lighter first week, and ask for administrative backend training so someone on your team owns automations and settings after go-live.
If you are also transitioning to Athelas RCM, coordinate training and implementation timelines with the managed billing team so your internal staff understand the new responsibilities and communication workflows.
How do I verify that a replacement EHR preserves our templates, flowsheets and outcome measures?
Rebuild your initial evaluation, post-op, injection and progress templates in a test, then compare every field and score against your current charts. Have a surgeon and a medical assistant sign off.
In Air, the Retention Engine reports functional outcome coverage at evaluation, progress note and discharge, so you can check measures after the move.
How do I evaluate implementation support after a previous software rollout went badly?
Ask who runs your project, what training covers on the administrative backend, and how automations are documented and handed over. Request a staged plan with checkpoints where you can pause.
Migrations can be completed in 30–60 days based on your practice complexity, and you can book time with the team to plan yours.
Can we use Athelas RCM without switching our orthopedic practice's EHR?
Yes. Athelas RCM can work alongside your existing EHR, allowing your practice to outsource revenue cycle operations without replacing its clinical system.
This can be a good option if your current EHR supports your clinical workflows but your practice wants a different approach to billing, claims management and collections.
What is the difference between Athelas Air and Athelas RCM?
Athelas Air is an AI-native EHR and practice management platform with billing software built in. It brings clinical documentation, scheduling and billing tools into one system, with your practice's team managing day-to-day billing operations.
Athelas RCM is a managed revenue cycle service. Athelas combines its software with a dedicated billing team to manage revenue cycle operations for your practice.
Practices can use Air on its own, RCM alongside an existing EHR or Air and RCM together for an integrated platform and managed billing support.
How long does an EHR migration take?
Migrations into Athelas Air can be completed in 30–60 days, depending on practice complexity and the data being transferred.
The full transition timeline should also account for staff training, integration testing, old-system access, billing vendor contracts and any parallel billing period. Book time with our team to discuss your current system and migration plan.
Sources



